Insights
How to Read a Notice of Funding Opportunity (the Way a Reviewer Will)
A federal notice of funding opportunity tells you how your application will be scored, if you know where to look. Go to the Application Review Information section, write down each criterion and its weight, and build your narrative around them in the same order. Many of the weak applications we see answer the program description instead.
What should I check first in a NOFO?
Before anyone starts writing, we run through five questions. If the answer to any of them is no, we usually stop there.
- Can we apply? Look at the list of eligible entity types and any cap on the number of applications per organization.
- Can we make the deadline? That includes having active SAM.gov and Grants.gov accounts, which take time to fix if they’ve lapsed.
- Can we cover the match? Check whether cost sharing is required and how it’s calculated.
- Is it worth it? Weigh the award size and the expected number of awards against the work of applying and, if you win, reporting.
- Does it fit what we already do? Read the program description for the outcomes the agency wants to pay for.
What are the sections of a NOFO?
Since the 2024 revision of the Uniform Guidance, federal agencies are supposed to use the same or similar headings in every notice of funding opportunity (2 CFR 200, Appendix I). That’s good news for applicants. Once you’ve read a few, you know where everything lives.
| Section | What it tells you | What to do with it |
|---|---|---|
| Basic Information | Total funding, expected number of awards, award size, key dates, and an executive summary | Judge your odds and the deadline before anything else |
| Eligibility | Who may apply, cost sharing, and what makes an application ineligible | Confirm you can apply at all |
| Program Description | The program’s goals and what the agency wants to fund | Check fit, but don’t write to this section alone |
| Application Contents and Format | Required forms, page limits, and formatting rules | Build your checklist and page budget |
| Submission Requirements and Deadlines | How and when to submit | Set internal deadlines days ahead |
| Application Review Information | The review criteria and how much each one counts | Organize your narrative around it |
| Award Notices | How and when awards are announced | Plan your start-up timeline |
| Post-Award Requirements and Administration | Reporting, terms and conditions, and special requirements | Decide whether you can manage the award |
| Other Information (optional) | Anything else the agency wants applicants to know | Skim for surprises |
You’ll still run into the older lettered format (Sections A through H) in some notices, so don’t worry if the headings don’t match exactly.
This format is a federal rule. State agencies and foundations write their own requests for proposals, and they may not publish point values. Read them the same way: find how they decide, and follow that order.
Four sections deserve a careful read before anyone writes a word: Eligibility, Basic Information (for the money and the number of awards, your best clue to the odds), Application Contents and Format (for page limits and forms), and Application Review Information (for how you’ll be scored).
Where are the review criteria in a NOFO?
In Application Review Information. Appendix I requires agencies to describe every criterion there and, if some count more than others, to say how much. The same section lists any screening criteria that can knock an application out before it’s scored.
The criteria usually appear as a list with points, something like this (we made up the numbers):
- Need for the project: 15 points
- Quality of the project design: 30 points
- Organizational capacity: 20 points
- Evaluation plan: 20 points
- Budget and budget justification: 15 points
Under each criterion there’s usually a paragraph telling reviewers what to look for. Read it slowly. Phrases like “the extent to which the applicant demonstrates” or “whether the applicant has identified” are the actual questions a reviewer has to score, and each one deserves an answer that’s easy to find.
We’ve found that reviewers do best with applications that follow the criteria in order, under matching headings. They’re usually working through a stack of applications with a scoring form built on those criteria, and when they have to hunt for an answer, they tend to score it cautiously.
How should I split the page limit?
By points. With a 25-page limit and the criteria above, that works out to about 4 pages on need, 7 or 8 on design, 5 each on capacity and evaluation, and whatever is left for the budget narrative if it counts against the limit. We often see the reverse: nine pages on need and three on evaluation, which spends the most space on a section worth fewer points.
Should I use the same words as the NOFO?
Yes. If the notice says “priority populations,” say “priority populations,” not “target communities.” If it defines “evidence-based” by pointing to a particular clearinghouse, cite that clearinghouse. Reviewers are matching your text against their rubric, and you want the match to be obvious.
What should I check in the post-award section before I apply?
Post-Award Requirements and Administration lists the reporting, the terms and conditions, and anything unusual about the program. It’s easy to skip because it feels like a problem for later. Read it anyway. Quarterly financial reports, a required data system, or an annual grantee meeting in another city all take staff time, and the application budget is your only chance to pay for them.
How do I check my application before I submit?
Hand it to someone who didn’t write it, give them the review criteria and the points, and ask them to score it without help. If they can’t find your answer to a criterion, you have a gap. If they find it and score it low, you have a weak spot. There’s still time to fix both.
If you’re starting the proposal from scratch, our grant proposal template and sample follows this structure, and the grant budget template covers the numbers. AI tools can help pull the criteria out of a long notice, with limits we cover in AI in grant writing.
Frequently asked questions
What is a NOFO?
A notice of funding opportunity is a federal agency’s announcement that funding is available, usually for a competitive grant or cooperative agreement. It explains who can apply, what the agency will fund, how to apply, and how applications will be scored.
Where are the review criteria in a NOFO?
In the section called Application Review Information. Federal rules require it to describe each criterion and, if they count differently, the weight of each one (2 CFR 200, Appendix I).
What sections does a federal NOFO have?
Basic Information, Eligibility, Program Description, Application Contents and Format, Submission Requirements and Deadlines, Application Review Information, Award Notices, and Post-Award Requirements and Administration, plus an optional Other Information section.
How do I know my chances of winning a federal grant?
Check Basic Information for the total funding and the expected number of awards. Fewer awards and more money per award usually mean more competition. Then check Eligibility to be sure you qualify.
Should my proposal follow the NOFO’s order?
Yes. Use headings that match the review criteria, in the same order, and use the notice’s own terms. Reviewers score against those criteria and find your answers faster.
Regulatory references: 2 CFR 200.204 (notices of funding opportunities); Appendix I to Part 200 (NOFO format); 2 CFR 200.205 (merit review); 2 CFR 200.206 (risk review).
This article is general information. It is not legal, tax, accounting, or financial advice, and reading it does not make you our client. Laws, regulations, and funder policies change, so check the cited sources and your own award terms before you act. Aventis West is not a law firm or an accounting firm. For advice on your own situation, talk to a qualified attorney or CPA. See our terms of use.
Working through this on a live application or award? Intro calls run about thirty minutes and cost nothing. Bring the funding notice or award letter and your next deadline.
Book an intro call